Saturday, July 23, 2022

The January 6th Hearings. Part 8: Dereliction of Duty

SCROTUS, you can dere-lick my balls. 



Actually, dereliction of duty is not the right term. As we saw in Thursday's primetime hearing of the U.S. House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol, it was not simply a failure to do his duty. Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) made the point that "he didn't fail to act, he chose not to." But even that is inadequate. It wasn't his choice to abscond his responsibilities to take action that was most troubling, though that certainly was quite troubling. It was his continued attempts to rile up the mob to do his dirty work even as he witnessed the horrendous deadly violence. 

It wasn't dereliction of duty. It was actively twisting the knife that he had thrust into the gut of our nation. 

The bulk of the hearing focused on the 187 minutes between the time SCROTUS finished his speech on the Ellipse at 1:10 p.m and when he put out his milquetoast video at 4:17 pm. The hearing was lead by Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) and Rep. Elaine Luria (D-Va.). The overall steerage was by Vice Chair Liz Cheney (R-Wy.) because Chair Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.) had tested positive for covid and appeared remotely. 

Two former Whitewash House officials offered live testimony. We heard from both Matthew Pottinger, deputy national security adviser from the first day of the term until the early morning hours of January 7, 2021 and Sarah Matthews, deputy press secretary who came aboard with Kayleigh McEnany. Matthews also resigned in the hours following the insurrection. Both of them were in the Whitewash House on January 6.

Through the hearing, the committee went minute by minute of those three hours, juxtaposing what was happening at the Capitol, with many clips from the Faux News broadcast to which Derelict Arnold was glued, alongside security footage from inside and outside the Capitol building, and also with what was happening in the Whitewash House dining room on the darkest day in our nation's history.

Buckle in. This one is dense.

Senator McTurtle 
The Committee, brilliantly, started the hearing with video of Senator Mitch McTurtle (R-Ala.), one of the Mango Mussolini's staunchest enablers. The senator forcefully condemned The Commander in Creep's actions and inactions on that day.
"A mob was assaulting the Capitol in his name. These criminals were carrying his banners, hanging his flags, and screaming their loyalty to him. It was obvious that only President Trump could end this. He was the only one."
Later in the hearing, they invoked Sen. McTurtle again. He spoke in the days after the insurrection:
"There's no question, none, that President Trump is practically and morally responsible for provoking the events of the day. No question about it. The people who stormed this building believed they were acting on the wishes and instructions of their President. And having that belief was a foreseeable consequence of the growing crescendo of false statements, conspiracy theories, and reckless hyperbole which the defeated President kept shouting into the largest megaphone on planet Earth."
As the committee pointed out, the senator did not have the benefit of reams of evidence from a year-long investigation like we have today. It was immediately obvious who was at fault. No question. None.

What Didn't Happen on January 6 
Official records of his activities that afternoon: we don't have them. Normally, a president has every action documented in official call logs and diary entries. Let's look at the records for January 6th, 2021. The official record of phone calls between the president* and anyone? None. The official diary entries, which normally documents 45's every waking moment? Blank. Photographs from the official photographer that is always nearby at every moment of every working day? Zippo. 

Corroboration 
Liz Cheney provided evidence that corroborated Cassidy Hutchinson's testimony about the activities in the presidential SUV just after the speech. At least two other witnesses testified to the "heated" exchange in the SUV and an "irate" president*. If only we had, I dunno, text messages from the secret service that might shed more light on the situation?

Secret Service on Standby 
After he failed to wrest the steering wheel (does he even know how to drive?) from his limo driver, T**** was delivered by the secret service to the Whitewash House. The limo and the security detail were placed on standby for nearly an hour, because da baby still wanted to go to the Capitol to participate in his coup in person. He didn't get to go. Instead, he did his second-favorite thing: he watched TV. I'll tell ya, the insurrection got great ratings! Tremendous! The highest ratings of any reality show!

The Island of Doctor Morose 
From the moment he got back to the Whitewash House until he was dragged kicking and screaming in front of the cameras late in the afternoon, he watched Faux News coverage of his coup attempt on his own little island: the dining room adjacent to the Oval Office. There he sat. For three hours at the dining room table, he watched a large flat-screen TV mounted opposite him, Faux News a-blarin'. Aides testified that's all that they saw him do. 

But he might have kept himself busy in other ways...


The First Hour: Watchin' the Boob Tube
1:10 p.m. The speech is finished. Before he even left the podium at the Ellipse, the trouble was brewing. Remember, long before this time, he knew the mob was armed. He sent them and their weapons toward the Capitol building to "fight like hell" and had told them he planned to join them. By 1:10 p.m., according to Rep. Luria, "the Vice President was in the Capitol. The joint session of Congress to certify Joe Biden's victory was underway and the Proud Boys and other rioters had stormed through the first barriers and begun the attack."

1:25 p.m. It took a couple minutes to drive back to the Whitewash House, and immediately POTATUS settled in front of the TV.

1:39 p.m. He called Rudy Giuliani (we only know this from Giuliani's phone records; official phone records are blank). He also called a bunch of Senators asking them to delay the count.

1:49 p.m. A riot is declared by D.C. police. At the same time, Twitler tweets a link to a replay of his speech. He stays silent on the violence.

Who did he call. A bunch of Senators, asking them to delay the certification. Among them was Sen. Tommy Tuberville (R-Ala.), who said that he had to hang up the phone with the Commander in Cheat because he was under siege had to freaking run for his life!
"He called — didn't call my phone. Called somebody else and they handed it to me. And I — I basically told him, I said Mr. President, we're — we're not doing much work here right now because they just took our Vice President out. And matter of fact I'm gonna have to hang up on you. I've got to leave."
Who he didn't call. Everybody else. There was silence. He did not place calls to the Attorney General, the Secretary of Homeland Security, the National Guard, the Capitol police, the mayor of the District of Columbia, the D.C. police, the FBI, the Secret Service, nor the Secretary of Defense. Any and all of those agencies could have garnered assistance to this volatile situation. He didn't call his Vice President, who was in mortal danger.

What was happening around him. Trumpty-Dumbty's closest staff, his top lawyers, and his family were all pleading with him to do something to call off the rioters. 

The Second Hour: Twisting the Knife
2:13 p.m. Vice President Pence was removed from the Senate Chambers. The president* knew Vice President Pence was running for his life, because Sen. Tommy Tuberville described to him that they had just taken the V.P. out of chambers. And in the next nine minutes, he composes a tweet.

2:24 p.m. Traitor Joe thrusts the knife a little deeper when he tweeted his odious message calling Pence a coward. Immediately the crowd glommed on to the tweet, spreading the news that "Pence screwed us" and soon the chants began, "Hang Mike Pence!" 

Ms. Matthews testified that this tweet sickened her and that she saw it as "pouring gasoline on the fire." She was shaken. It was after this tweet that Mr. Pottinger decided to resign. He also thought of it as adding fuel to the fire. 

Shortly after the infamous tweet, the vice president was preparing to evacuate a second time.

"We may lose the ability to leave." 
At 2:26 p.m. Pence evacuated the second time. Rioters were just 40 feet away as his security detail tried to evacuate him to safety. 

One of the most wrenching moments from the hearings so far was the audio from radio traffic between secret service agents, trying desperately to find a quick and safe escape for Pence. It was absolutely heart-wrenching to hear the radio transmissions as they frantically tried to find an escape route for the Vice President of the United States. The committee also played emotionally-laden audio testimony of one voice-disguised witness who testified that agents were putting calls through to their families to say goodbye. 

They were preparing to die that day.

Hawley-ing Ass!
Around this time, Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) also high-tailed it out to safety. The committee absolutely reamed him. They were scathing in their description of Hawley and how he had "riled up the crowd" that morning with his famous raised fist only to later scamper through the building to hide from his mob.

Here's their presentation to that end. Notice the natural laughtrack.


Comedians have been *ahem* running with Hawley's fleet-footed flee.

Thanks sister resister Pagrs for pointing me to this image



Clay Jones




Pence Takes Charge 
Ultimately Mike Pence was moved safely – at a normal, but urgent pace – to an underground loading dock, where he stayed the rest of the day and into the night. What did he do? He took charge. He made phone calls. 

He called Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Mark Milley; he called Secretary of Defense Christopher Miller. He worked to get help to the law enforcement who was so badly overrun. Gen. Milley was surprised at the Wanker in Chief's lack of action, saying, “You know, you’re the commander in chief. You’ve got an assault going on in the Capitol of the United States of America. And there’s nothing? No call? Nothing? Zero?” 

Gen. Milley said Pence was "very animated and he issued very explicit, very direct, unambiguous orders. There was no question about that.... He was very animated, very direct, very firm. And to Secretary Miller, get the military down here, get the guard down here, put down this situation, etc."

In the meantime, aides in the Whitewash House were scrambling to change the narrative. Gen. Milley recalls a call from Mark Meadows: "He said, we have — we have to kill the narrative that the Vice President is making all the decisions. We need to establish the narrative that, you know, that the President is still in charge and that things are steady or stable."

2:38 p.m. Members of Congress who were unable to leave the House chamber were cowering in the gallery, fearing for their lives, donning gas masks, and removing their congressional pins so as to avoid being identified as members of Congress. You remember the video. 

 

This is what Lex Loser was seeing on Faux News at that 2:38 p.m. moment, just about the time he put out the tweet below. (Note: the videos below start at the correct point, but YouTube does not give me the option to clip, so you're on your own to stop the video)



2:38 p.m. As members of Congress were fearfully running for their lives, or flattened against the floor of the gallery, the Bloat of Many Colors tweeted this inane message: "Please support our Capitol Police and Law Enforcement. They are truly on the side of our Country. Stay peaceful!"

He had to be cajoled by his daughter to include the phrase "stay peaceful" in this tweet. Ms. Matthews stated that he didn't want to have the word "peace" in there at all but finally relented with Ivanka's urging. 

"He didn't say not to do anything to the Congressmen." 
Ali Alexander knew that the insurrectionists were "not ignorant of what his words would do." Orange You Glad He's Not President knew how his words would twist the knife. How did the mob react to this tweet? Here's communications between several members of the Oath Keepers just after the 2:38 tweet. Chilling.

(again, stop the video when you see fit)


The Third Hour: Fingers in His Ears "La - la- la! Can't hear you!"
What was happening at the Whitewash House? Shortly after his 2:24 and 2:38 tweets, there came a barrage of entreaties from several members of Congress, allies, and family members to Chief of Staff Mark Meadows, asking earnestly that the president* issue a statement or a tweet or anything to call off the mob. (Evidence from the hearing, also some of these are from CNN's reporting):

2:28 p.m. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.): "Mark I was just told there is an active shooter on the first floor of the Capitol Please tell the President to calm people This isn't the way to solve anything," 

2:32 p.m. Faux News's Laura Ingraham: "Hey Mark, The president needs to tell people in the Capitol to go home. This is hurting all of us."

2:34 p.m., North Carolina-based Repug strategist Carlton Huffman: "You've earned a special place in infamy for the events of today. And if you're the Christian you claim to be in your heart you know that."

2:35 p.m. former chief of staff Mick Mulvaney: "Mark: he needs to stop this, now. Can I do anything to help?"

2:44 p.m. Rep. Barry Loudermilk (R-Ga.): "They have breached the Capitol. It's really bad up here on the hill." 

2:46 p.m. Rep. Will Timmons (R-S.C.) : "The president needs to stop this ASAP."

2:53 p.m. Don Junior: "He's got to condemn this shit ASAP. The Capitol Police tweet is not enough." 

3:09 p.m. Kevin McCarthy finally got through via phone to Ivanka as well as Jared, then finally to the president* (see below). 

3:11 p.m. Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-Wis.) issued a video tweet directly speaking to 45 asking him to "Call. It. Off."

3:13 Communications aide Alyssa Farah Griffen: "Potus has to come out firmly and tell protestors to dissipate. Someone is going to get killed."

3:13 p.m. Dr. Do-Little issues another inane tweet, knowing that there were terrible things happening.


3:15 p.m. Rep. Chip Roy (R-Tx.): "Fix this now."

3:31 p.m. Faux News personality and minion Sean Hannity: "Can he make a statement. I saw the tweet. Ask people to peacefully leave the capital"

3:42 p.m., North Carolina-based lobbyist Tom Cors: "Pls have POTUS call this off at the Capitol. Urge rioters to disperse. I pray to you."

3:52 p.m., North Carolina lawyer Jay Leutze: "Mark, this assault in the Capitol is tragic for the country. Please call it off so the Congress can resume its peaceful debate."

3:58 p.m. Faux News performer Brian Kilmeade: "Please get him on tv. Destroying every thing you guys have accomplished."

4:08 p.m. President-elect Joe Biden makes an video entreaty: "I call on President Trump to go on national television now, to fulfill his oath and defend the Constitution, and demand an end to this siege." 

Ms. Matthews testified that another staffer resisted having the president* condemn the violence because that would "hand a win to the media." WTAF? Matthews thought the same as me, retorting, "And so, I motioned up at the TV and I said do you think it looks like we're effing winning? Because I don't think it does."

The McCarthy Factor 
After 3:00 p.m., House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Cal.) called Jared, getting him out of the shower, and relayed to him that he "was scared." At 3:09 p.m., McCarthy finally got through and spoke to the president* directly, imploring him to do something. The conversation went something like this, according to Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler (R-Wash.):
"And he said you have got to get on TV, you've got to get on Twitter, you've got to call these people off. You know what the president said to him? This is as it's happening. He said, 'Well, Kevin, these aren't my people. You know, these are — these are Antifa.' And Kevin responded and said 'No, they're your people. They literally just came through my office windows and my staff are running for cover. I mean, they're running for their lives. You need to call them off.' And the president's response to Kevin, to me, was chilling. He said, 'Well, Kevin, I guess they're just more upset about the election, you know, theft than you are.' And that's — you know, you've seen widespread reports of — of Kevin McCarthy and the president having a — basically a swearing conversation. That's when the swearing commenced, because the president was basically saying, 'Nah, I — I'm okay with this.'"
In the days after January 6, McCarthy continued to be scathing in his condemnation of the president's* behavior, saying among other things, 
"The President bears responsibility for Wednesday's attack on Congress by mob rioters. He should have immediately denounced the mob when he saw what was unfolding. These facts require immediate action by President Trump."
 and 
"But let me be very clear to all of you, and I've been very clear to the president. He bears responsibility for his words and actions, no ifs, ands, or buts. I asked him personally today does he hold responsibility for what happened? Does he feel bad about what happened? He told me he does have some responsibility for what happened and he needed to acknowledge that."

and 

"I've had it with this guy. What he did is unacceptable. Nobody can defend that and nobody should defend it. The only discussions I would have with him is that I think this will pass and it would be my recommendation he should resign. I mean, that would be my take, but I don't think he would take it, but I don't know. But let me be very clear to all of you, and I've been very clear to the president. He bears responsibility for his words and actions, no ifs, ands, or buts. I asked him personally today does he hold responsibility for what happened? Does he feel bad about what happened? He told me he does have some responsibility for what happened and he needed to acknowledge that."
Since that day, as you know, McCarthy has gotten back in the lap of his Honey Bear. 

They be Tired Babies: "Day's Over"
3:58 p.m. Finally, after more than three hours of chaos and violence, the TV in the Whitewash House dining room showed Faux News reporting that the DOD had brought in the National Guard at the V.P's request. 

4:03 p.m. It was only after he understood that the National Guard was taking control and rousting the mob away from the Capitol building that the Tangerine Toddler finally relented to his allies' begging and headed to the Rose Garden to film a statement. 

Finally, at 4:17 p.m., after a full afternoon of urging, 45 released the video message telling the rioters to leave the Capitol. The video he tweeted was just over a minute long. He refused to have it scripted. His remarks were off-the-cuff and characteristically disgusting. You remember the video. They had done his bidding, so he told his murderous mob that he "loves them" and that they "are very special." If you need a refresher, here it is, along with never-before-seen outtakes. 


That was the moment that Ms. Matthews decided to resign. It was all too much. 

Immediately after the video was released, many of the insurrectionists took the president's* message as marching orders and spread the word that their supreme leader ordered them to disperse. It was pretty clear from the evidence that they were indeed hanging on his words and literally took them as orders. They said so! Several of the rioters reacted:


For the folks at the Whitewash House, immediately after the video was released at 4:17, Whitewash House attorney Eric Herschmann testified that everyone was all tuckered out. "We were all emotionally drained," he said. "Day's over." Poor babies! Go get some rest!

Meanwhile, back at the riots.....cops were still being beaten unconscious. Insurrectionists were still trying to beat down the doors. Violence continued. You can see the video in the hearing.

And at this same time, our government officials were figuring out how they could get back into chambers and finish the People's business. Pence was making phone calls strategizing a quick, safe return to the building. Speaker Pelosi and Sen. Schumer were also figuring out their way back. They were determined not to let the day's events delay the official certification. 

At 6:01p.m., just in case the knife didn't meet the artery, Twitler adjusted his grip and thrust once more. He sent an inflammatory tweet justifying the violence: "These are the things and events that happen when a sacred landslide election victory is so unceremoniously & viciously stripped away from great patriots who have been badly & unfairly treated for so long. Go home with love & in peace. Remember this day forever!"

6:27 p.m. Don the Con retires to the residence for the night. The last thing he says to an aide, and about the only thing he has said all day, "Mike Pence let me down." 

7:02 p.m. Rudy Giuliani called Sen. Tuberville as if nothing had happened! He was still asking to delay the proceedings. Seriously, man?! Weren't you watching TV today!?

3:00 a.m. Finally, Congress was able to return to the chambers. They certified the election results just before 4 a.m. Yes, some members objected to the vote. Yes, they all had to engage in debate with the idiots (Primary idiot Haulin' Hawley was front and center objecting to certification and voting against it). At the Whitewash House, we can only assume IMPOTUS was staring and the ceiling and stewing.

That Ship Has Sailed. There was some discussion on what statement to release after certification finally happened. Campaign advisor Jason Miller took it upon himself and set about composing a statement. His boss suggested that the statement include the phrase "peaceful transition of power." Miller flatly replied, "That ship's kind of already sailed." ...How about "orderly transition?" Miller said that was about all the discussion that was had about the message.

3:49 a.m. The tweet went out from Deputy Chief of Staff for Communication Dan Scavino's Twitter account because @realdonaldtrump had been finally been suspended. 
January 7Those Outtakes Though! 
The next day, under threat of calls for resignation or invoking the 25th Amendment, those that surrounded the president* again dragged him, if not literally kicking and screaming then slamming and pouting, and they made him make another video statement to affirm that he would commit to an orderly transition of power. This one was heavily scripted, and he was visibly angry as read the words. Some of the words, like the word "yesterday" were difficult for him to say. Others, like "the election is over" nearly choked him.  

A visibly angry T**** could not bring himself to say the election was over. 

He was definitely in Toddler Mode, and in the end he just looked small and incompetent.

Watch:



More Deafening Silence
45 has never acknowledged the loss of the lives of LEOs. Director of communications Tim Murtaugh noted this void in messages with one of his deputies, Matthew Wolking:

Murtaugh texted to Wolking, "Also shitty not to have acknowledged the death of the Capitol Police officer." Wolking responded, "That's enraging to me. Everything he said about supporting law enforcement was a lie." Murtaugh replied, "You know what this is of course? If he acknowledged the dead cop, he'd be implicitly faulting the mob. And he won't do that because they're his people. And it would also be close to acknowledging that what he lit at the rally got out of control. No way he acknowledges something that could ultimately be called his fault. No way."

He has, by contrast, acknowledged the tragic death of Ashli Babbit. Not as a terrible, senseless death for which he is remorseful and bears responsibility. No, he has turned her into a martyr. Just another pawn in his repulsive propaganda game. 

Oath be Damned 
It's doubtful POTATUS ever remembered or cared that he took an oath to defend the Constitution of the United States. He is not one to care about promises, ethics, or duty. But as a country, we do. We care a lot. Because keeping our promises is what individuals do in order to honor each other and the rule of law.

Thursday's witness Matt Pottinger took the oath multiple times in various capacities in his service to the nation. He holds the oath sacrosanct. He remarked, "It is to — to support and defend the Constitution. It's to protect the Constitution, to bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution. And it is a sacred oath. It's an oath that we take before our families. We take that oath before God. And I think that we have an obligation to live by — by that oath."

The Message to The Former Guy
Liz Cheney was clear in her words. The dam is breaking. More witnesses are coming forward. The snake oil salesman won't be able to wiggle out of this.

The Message to the Trumpkins
We know you are patriotic, but you've been duped, and it's not your fault. In her closing statement, Cheney said:
"Donald Trump knows that millions of Americans who supported him would stand up and defend our nation were it threatened. They would put their lives and their freedom at stake to protect her. And he is preying on their patriotism. He is preying on their sense of justice.

And on January 6th, Donald Trump turned their love of country into a weapon against our Capitol and our Constitution. He has purposely created the false impression that America is threatened by a foreign force controlling voting machines or that a wave of tens of millions of false ballots were secretly injected into our election system or that ballot workers have secret thumb drives and are stealing elections with them.

All complete nonsense. We must remember that we cannot abandon the truth and remain a free nation. "
Honoring the Sister Resisters
Liz Cheney made it a point to praise the women who have come forward to testify, including Cassidy Hutchinson and Thursday's witness, Sarah Matthews. In her opening statement she said, 

"And let me again thank our witnesses today. We've seen bravery and honor in these hearings. And Ms. Matthews and Mr. Pottinger, both of you will be remembered for that. As will Cassidy Hutchinson. She sat here alone took the oath and testified before millions of Americans. She knew all along that she would be attacked by President Trump and by the 50, 60, and 70 year old men who hide themselves behind executive privilege.

But like our witnesses today, she has courage and she did it anyway. Cassidy, Sarah, and our other witnesses including Officer Caroline Edwards, Shaye Moss and her mother, Ruby Freeman, are an inspiration to American women and to American girls. We owe a debt to all of those who have and will appear here."

Her remarks were likely in response to the GOP wanting to eat their own. Of course, the GOP hates women in general, but the day before this hearing, Garrett Ziegler, a former aide to Dan Scavino, posted this misogynistic, racist rant. Those people are just disgusting. Through and through. (Thanks to sister resister Anne for pointing me to this)

Other News that May Inform the Investigation
  • Steve Bannon was found guilty of contempt of Congress. Sentencing will be in October. Minimum sentence: 30 days. Witnesses, take note! Cooperate or else! We will get to the truth. 
  • Investigations continue into the deleted tweets from the secret service. There are criminal investigations underway and some secret service agents have retained attorneys. Read here to catch up on that scandal. It's looking very dark.
  • And regarding the secret service, I was concerned to read a follow-up regarding possibly different reasons that Pence did not leave the Capitol grounds on January 6. You remember Anthony Ornato, who has refuted in the press – not under oath – Cassidy Hutchinson's claims about the ride in the SUV that day. He is the individual who oversaw secret service protection, and he is also a staunch T**** loyalist – he had a position in the administration between stints with the secret service. Ornato had been pushing that day for Pence to leave the Capitol grounds. Was Pence afraid that the secret service was complicit in the coup? I know it's a little conspiracy-theory-y, but Ornato is turning out to be not a very good guy. We need to hear from him under oath. He is one of the ones who has lawyered up. There's some about this angle in the article above, but you can hear more about the puzzle pieces surrounding the V.P.'s evacuation from an April MSNBC piece.
The Future 
Hearings will resume in September. If indeed "the dam has broken" and evidence and witnesses continue to roll in, they will have lots more to present. You can bet I will be glued to the television and right back here after. 

Thank You
As long as this post is, I've only touched on the evidence presented during this hearing. Thanks for hanging in there until the end. 

I encourage to you please watch the entire proceedings for yourself. It's important. See you in a few weeks. Thanks for reading!






Wednesday, July 13, 2022

The January 6th Hearings. Part 7: Assembling the Mob

For three hours, all this atheist could get out was "Jesus!" "My gawd!" "Holy christ on a cracker." "Dear lordt are you kidding me?" 

You know it's serious.

On Tuesday we watched another jaw-dropping, chock-full-o'-facts hearing of the U.S. House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol. This one focused on the Smelly Cheese's last-ditch plan for his coup: to set a violent mob upon the Capitol building. The building where our 535 representatives and senators, the vice president, and all of their staff members, were conducting the business of the People: certifying the Electoral College votes and officially declaring Joseph Robinette Biden Jr as our 46th president-elect.

The hearing featured statements and questioning by Rep. Stephanie Murphy (D-Fla.) and Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) 

The committee illustrated that it was clear to the outgoing president* that he had lost the election by December 14, 2020, when the Electoral College met and cast their votes, declaring that Biden had won the election by a vote of 306 to 232 electors.

All of his previous coup plot points had failed: he failed to win in the courts; he failed to strong-arm the state election officials and legislators; he failed to corrupt the Department of Justice; he failed to subvert the Electoral College; he failed to bully Mike Pence into abandoning his oath. The only "winning" he had in his pocket was his massive deception of millions of Americans who believed him. And, on his bidding, tens of thousands of them descended upon Washington D.C. that Wednesday, January 6. He would see to it that they would do his dirty work.

The committee started by laying the blame entirely at SCROTUS's feet. They rejected any attempts at blaming the ne'er-do-wells that orbited him. As Lyn Cheney succinctly put it: 
"President Trump is a 76-year-old man. He is not an impressionable child. Just like everyone else in our country, he is responsible for his own actions and his own choices. As our investigation has shown, Donald Trump had access to more detailed and specific information showing that the election was not actually stolen than almost any other American, and he was told this over and over again. No rational or sane man in his position could disregard that information and reach the opposite conclusion. And Donald Trump cannot escape responsibility by being willfully blind, nor can any argument of any kind excuse President Trump's behavior during the violent attack on January 6th."
 Full stop.

Contrast with a real statesman president:

President Harry S Truman posing in the reproduction of the Oval Office at the Truman Library in 1959. The sign "The Buck Stops Here" was given to Truman by Fred M. Canfil on October 2, 1945. (Truman Library)

The committee reminded us that there was no evidence of fraud. Every official in his orbit knew there was no evidence. He was told there was no evidence over and over and over. They encouraged him to concede after the Electoral College met on December 14. But he still managed to find some sycophants that would help him assert the Big Lie and feed him what he wanted. And on December 18, 2020, some of those weasels got into the Oval Office and decided to conspire some more.

The Unhinged Meeting
On the evening of December 18, Team Crazy convened. That attorney from outer space Sydney Powell, the attorney from the bottom of the whiskey barrel, Rudy Giuliani, the CEO from Overstock.com (who?), and the most treasonous American since the Rosenbergs, Mike Flynn, all snuck in a side door into the White House and met with their supreme leader. 

Jesus.

They had been talking for 10-15 minutes before the president's official advisors got wind of it and sprinted to the Oval Office. It seems "Pat Cipollone set a new land speed record" according to Powell. It was at this meeting that Powell pushed her theories that long-deceased Hugo Chavez and Valezuelans had messed with the Dominion voting machines. Flynn promoted a theory that Nest thermostats were involved in connecting communications from around the world. 

Dear lordt are you kidding me? 

Team Normal soon joined the meeting. It got heated. And then it became, as Cassidy Hutchinson described it, "unhinged." For the next several hours -- about six hours -- this "meeting" turned ugly. What ensued? Screaming, flying insults, and it nearly came to fisticuffs! It moved like a schoolyard rumble from the Oval Office to the Roosevelt Room, to the "Yellow Oval," which is the president's office in the residence, and back again. 

Holy christ on a cracker. 

The Toddler-in-Chief wanted to draft an executive order to seize voting machines from the states. He also, by virtue of his saying so, named Sydney Powell as special prosecutor and granted that whack-job security clearance! The Whitewash House advisors in Team Normal tried to push back on the cray-cray conspiracy theorists. Giuliani gleefully recalled that he called the advisors "pussies" and at one point had been alone in the Cabinet Room, "which is kind of cool. I really liked that, all my — all by myself."

My gawd.

Cipallone and others all described the chaos within in the Unhinged Meeting and the one question weaving throughout the evening that was never answered: Where is the evidence?

Finally, sometime after midnight, Mark Meadows himself escorted Giuliani out, as Cassidy Hutchinson said, to "make sure he didn't wander back into the mansion." The ruckus finally ended. Did this mean that the president* took the better advice of his inner circle and decided to finally concede? HA! No! Shortly thereafter, at 1:42 a.m. on December 19, 2020, Twitler issued his beckoning tweet. 


And after that, he tweeted more than a dozen times to promote the event.

The Organization
His devoted followers took his tweet and ran. Social media was buzzing from the get-go. The very next day, they started to organize. Hours after his 1:42 a.m. tweet, Women for America First, a pro-T**** organization, changed the permit for their rally from January 22 to January 6. And in the following days, a disturbing alliance began forming between far-right militia groups such as the Proud Boys and the Oath Keepers. Homeland Security intelligence official Dr. Donell Harvin described how after the initial tweet there developed a "blended ideology" as nonaligned groups became aligned. He became quite concerned.

King Ketchup knew his followers were ready for war. Keep in mind that Roger Stone and Michael Flynn were both closely aligned with these groups. The groups' leaders saw an opportunity for legitimacy as they communicated and coordinated with those traitors. Stone and Flynn, of course, are close allies of 45, and there is no way that he did not know what was brewing. 

It came to light after the hearing that the committee chose to forego illustrating the ties the Traitor-in-Chief had to the alt-right groups in favor of including long-sought testimony from Pat Cipollone. I hope they show that evidence. It will be in their final report, but it is important for us to see it. 

Social media developed a growing hum, with all the alt-right groups' planning and coordination. They were whipped up by people such as Alex Jones and Ali Alexander, de facto alt-right leaders and agitators. The language in videos and tweets were clearly war-like. "Locked and loaded," lists of weapons to bring, cries of "1776!" and "Ready for civil war!" The website thedonald.win had discussions going about the tunnel system in the Capitol building. Even "milder" Steve Bannon made a provocative video the day before the 6th. It was all there, in plain sight and in plain language. They had accepted the president's* invitation and were gearing for war.

Deaf Ears
The committee wasn't the first one to connect the dots between The Tangerine Toddler's tweeted invitation and continuing promotion of the January 6 event and the alt-right's open organization. At least one Twitter employee expressed concern about the growing chatter. This individual (who was anonymous and voice-disguised in their testimony) had urged Twitter to take action reigning in T**** ever since his "stand back and stand by" comments during the September 29th presidential debate. The warnings were ignored. The Twitter employee's concern only grew after the December 19 tweet, but their concerns continued to be dismissed. They testified that if it were any other person on the planet, the account would have been shut down long before. The day before the 6th, they said, they feared the violence that was coming. 

The Congressional Conspirators
On December 21, several Republican members of Congress met with the President to discuss the upcoming certification ceremony. These members of the U.S. House of Representatives were invited to the Whitewash House to discuss the "Eastman theory," that Pence could reject the count and interrupt the peaceful transfer of power. It's the usual suspects:
  • Mo Brooks
  • Brian Babin
  • Andy Biggs
  • Matt Gaetz
  • Louie Gohmert
  • Paul Gosar
  • Andy Harris
  • Jody Hice
  • Jim Jordan
  • Scott Perry
  • Marjorie Taylor Greene

The Night Before the Insurrection
The committee outlined TΠ―UMP's activities on the night before the 6th. 

First, he spoke to Steve Bannon twice that day. After his first phone call, Bannon made a video and said, "All hell is going to break loose tomorrow. It's all converging and now we're on, as they say, the point of attack, right, the point of attack tomorrow. I'll tell you this, it's not going to happen like you think it's going to happen, Ok? It's going to be quite extraordinarily different. And all I can say is strap in." Strap in. Point of attack. Are those not words of war?

Later that day, there was a rally at the Freedom Plaza, just a couple blocks as the crow flies from the Whitewash House. The Douche of Hazard brought his aides into the Oval Office and insisted on opening the door so that he could hear the rally. He was quite excited and fired up about the energy coming from the rally. 

At the rally, people like Roger Stone, Michael Flynn, and Ali Alexander were riling the crowd with more war-like rhetoric. 

As he sat in the Oval Office listening to the rally, he tweeted "Washington is being inundated with people who don't want to see an election victory stolen by emboldened radical left Democrats. Our country has had enough. They won't take it anymore. To the crowds gathering in DC he added, we hear you and love you from the Oval Office." 

Then he set about revising his speech.

The Rhetoric 
It was the rhetoric that brought his troops to the front, and it was his words that sent them to do violence. 45 knew that his words were powerful to his followers. You recall from a prior hearing that SCROTUS had a phone call with Mike Pence the morning of the 6th, in which he became very agitated and called Pence a "wimp" and a "pussy" for resisting the pressure to break the law and refuse to certify the electoral votes. After that phone call, he wanted to re-write his speech to include statements about Mike Pence. 

He and his speech writer swamp lizard Stephen Miller set about adding lines like, "we will see whether Mike Pence enters history as a truly great and courageous leader. All he has to do is refer the illegally submitted electoral votes back to the states that were given false and fraudulent information where they want to recertify." After much back and forth with the lawyers, they removed that line but added one reference to Pence. True to form, however, the next morning the Commander-in-Cheese ad-libbed seven more statements about Pence as he spoke to the armed crowd. The word "peacefully" was removed and words about "fighting" were inserted. And he ad-libbed numerous references to going to the Capitol, including the one about him joining them.

He knew exactly what he was doing.

Live Witnesses
We heard from two live witnesses, one regular Joe from Ohio who participated in the Insurrection but was not part of any organized group, and the former media director of the Oath Keepers, who had resigned from the organization years ago and was not in Washington D.C. that day. 

Stephen Ayers from Ohio gave us some insight into the many participants who were not part of any group. He testified that he bought all of what Uncle Scam was selling. In his gee-whiz Hicksville drawl, his testimony pretty much consisted of, "Welp, we went cuz 45 asked us to. When he told us to leave, we did."

Simple, but telling: They truly believed him, and they were simply following orders. 

Ayers gave good advice to the millions who still "hang on every word" of the former president*: "Biggest thing for me is take the blinders off, make sure you step back and see what's going on before it's too late."

Ayers has pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct during the insurrection and will be sentenced in September.

The second witness, Jason Van Tatenhove, was entrenched with the Oath Keepers for years as a media guy. He worked for the group from approximately 2014 to 2016. Van Tatenhove issued a stark warning about this group, saying they are a dangerous armed militia and have nefarious goals. He testified that the Oath Keepers are a dangerous paramilitary organization and that January 6th fit into their goals of a violent revolution. One shocking tidbit that Van Tatenhove offered was that the leader of the Oath Keepers, Stewart Rhodes, wanted him to develop a deck of cards, like those the military had during the Middle East conflicts, with political enemies depicted, including Hillary Clinton as the queen of hearts.

The Final Bombshell of the Day 
Lyn Cheney did what she does best: dropped another stick of dynamite in the final moments of the hearing. She revealed that a witness that has met with the committee, but that the public hasn't heard from yet, got a call from Don the Con himself. Instead of answering the call or responding, the witness alterted their lawyer who alerted the committee. The matter has been turned over to the DOJ.

Ann Telnaes


The Next Hearing
The eighth, and presumably final, hearing will be next week. It is expected to take place on Thursday, July 21 during primetime. We'll hear about the actions, or rather inactions, that Old McFraudle undertook during the day on January 6. Check your local listings, and head over to the Church of LSR afterwards.

In the meantime, if you missed it, here is Tuesday's hearing in its entirety. 






Click here for Part 8: Dereliction of Duty

Wednesday, July 6, 2022

The Audacity of Heinz: Cartoons and Thoughts

After last week's televised hearing of the U.S. House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol, the artists in the political cartoon arena came out in force. 

Thanks to Sister Resister Pagrs for pointing me to some of these, as well as The Week

I appreciate these artists so much! (Side note: where my female cartoonists at?!)



Jack Ohman

Pat Byrnes

Chris Britt

Dave Whamond

Bill Bramhall

David Horsey

Drew Sheneman

Clay Jones

Clay Jones

Mike Luckovich

Marshall Ramsey

Steve Benson

Steve Kelly


Lalo Alcatraz

John Deering


So. Thoughts.

Will there be justice? Friends have been asking me, "Do you think they'll put 45 in jail?"

The Department of Justice must move forward with indictment. Whether or not it will be perfect justice is another question. Imperfect justice is better than no justice. 

Some say, "There will be such a backlash from the right if they move to indict. Think of what they will do!" News Flash: they've done it. They attempted a violent coup! We cannot let that stand unpunished. If we are truly a nation of laws, no one is above the law. Everyone involved with the coup, from the bottom to the tippy top, MUST be prosecuted. 

And as Liz Cheney said in a recent interview, not moving forward with prosecution of 45 would be more dangerous to the country. On ABC's "This Week," she said:
 I have greater concern about what it would mean if people weren’t held accountable for what’s happened here. I think it’s a much graver constitutional threat if a president can engage in these kinds of activities and, you know, the majority of the president's party looks away or we as a country decide, you know, we're not actually going to take our constitutional obligations seriously. I think that’s a much -- a much more serious threat.
Who should get indicted? All of them. The DOJ has done a pretty good job of identifying (well, they identified themselves on social media) the seditionists in the crowd. But up from there: Giuliani, Meadows, state officials who conspired, all those members of Congress who aided and abetted, and the former president* most of all. 

Nearly 60% of those polled by ABC/Ipsos agree with me. 

So, to answer the question: I think 45 will be indicted on some charge or other. Whether he goes to jail is a whole 'nother question. He seems to be as slippery as a snake covered in his own snake oil when it comes to consequences.

The Committee. The Committee has been masterful laying out the case. Each hearing has had a theme, and they have kept it simple and easy to understand who and what comprised each part of the nefarious plan. Each hearing has been a simple and direct presentation of the facts. 

They have done a great job of weaving video testimony, live testimony, and other video evidence and documents. It has been good TV. The video presentations have been mighty powerful. The committee has former ABC News exec James Goldston to thank. He has been producing the powerful videos and advising the committee on their presentations. 

The Committee itself cannot bring criminal charges, but they can make criminal referrals to Attorney General Merrick Garland. Those referrals would hold no legal water, but the DOJ does not need a referral to bring charges anyway. And they are performing their own investigations. The Committee has laid out numerous chargeable offenses neatly and clearly with evidence. The possible charges against 45 being floated around by pundits:
  • Obstructing an official proceeding
  • Conspiracy to defraud the United States
  • Seditious Conspiracy
  • Obstruction of Justice

The tell. It's telling that after the damning testimony from Cassidy Hutchinson, the right glommed onto the grabbing-the-steering-wheel vignette as the one to contest. 
  • Allowing weapons knowingly to the rally on the Ellipse? It's a given. 
  • Sending that armed mob to the Capitol, asking them to "fight for me"? No dispute. 
  • Witness intimidation, from the top? Eh, it is the way. 
  • Urging his followers to murder the Vice President of the United States? Pence deserved it. 
  • Grabbing the steering wheel and lunging at an agent to try to get to the Capitol? THAT WOULD BE IMPOSSIBLE IF HE WERE SITTING IN THE BACKSEAT! HE WASN'T IN THE BEAST – HE WAS IN A SUV! SHE LIES! SHE LIES!

The backlash. It's getting ugly out there. Listen to what people have said when they call into Rep. Adam Kinzinger's (R-Ill.) office. Warning: foul, disturbing language!

I've always urged my readers to contact your members of Congress. I want to make clear that I would never, ever advocate words or actions like this. Please, continue to contact your MoCs. But please, always always be civil and direct to the point of what you want them to do on your behalf. Be the better person. Every time. 

The next hearing. The next hearing will be next Tuesday, July 12 at 10 a.m. Eastern time, 7 a.m. Pacific. A witness list has not been released, but it will focus on the crime of assembling a mob: the financing, the organization, the participants. Watch with care: don't hurt your jaw when it drops again. 

See you after. 


Monday, July 4, 2022

Have Hope this Independence Day. Or the Fascists Will Have Won.

Another Independence Day, another struggle. Do we feel like celebrating? 

We need to dig deep again in 2022. Maybe the deepest yet. 

"Patriotism is supporting your country all the time, and your government when it deserves it." – Mark Twain

Here we are, on our most patriotic holiday, our hallowed Independence Day, when we not only celebrate the founding of our country, but all the freedoms that our founding fathers set forth, the progress we have made, and the promise of a more perfect union.

It hasn't been easy in recent years to feel proud of the U.S. In 2020, we were sickened on Independence Day when we had to witness the brazen racism in South Dakota. The year before that, it was hard to feel proud when SCROTUS was planning his Ego Fest Military Parade Rally N Shit. In 2018, friends were quite broken-hearted and finding it hard to be patriotic in the face of the news that children were being separated from their families and held in cages

And now, our rights are being stripped from us, bad people tried to violently take the country away from us, and the United States is becoming a dangerous place, especially for people of color and women. 

But I ask you again, please, dig deep and find your patriotism. Find that kind of patriotism that means supporting the country's ideals, its potential, its best. Cling not to pride for the past, nor the now, but hope for the future. If we don't embrace that hope, then we've given up and the fascists win. 

Patriotism means dissent. 
Patriotism means hope.
Patriotism means optimism.
Patriotism means participation.
Patriotism means effort.
Patriotism means resilience.
Patriotism means resistance.

What does patriotism mean to you?

As Adlai Stevenson II said, "Patriotism is not a short and frenzied outburst of emotion but the tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime." And so, let us be steadily patriotic today, and tomorrow, and the day after that. Let us support the country all the time, even when the government doesn't deserve it. It is our patriotism that will save the United States of America.

There is a movement out there to wear black for Independence Day as a statement against the Supreme Court's decision. I understand; it's a time for mourning. Yet I say to wear the red, white, and blue. It is powerful symbolism. Do not hand it over to those who would pervert it. Really? We're going to turn our flag over to the MAGATS who "love the country" so much that they would overthrow the government? No. Reclaim the flag. "The shame is on the other side." (David Bowie, Heroes)

Fly your flag today for the potential it holds. 

Engage in meaningful celebrations today. Spend time with friends and family. Let your heart swell as you watch the fireworks. 

You can feel outraged the whole time. Feeling disgusted and angry is feeling Patriotic! The reason you are furious and less-than-patriotic is because you instill the very hope and the values that are at our base. Feel the fury! We must not abandon American ideals now! We know that over the last 245 years, we've made progress. We have much more progress to make, and we can't give up now. We must, more than ever, embrace the standards that have driven Americans.

So, go! Enjoy your hotdogs and fireworks today. Create celebrations as well as self-care. Dig down and find your strength as individuals so that we can, together, lift America out of this pit. We need to work hard to make it better!

“Nothing in this world is worth having or worth doing unless it means effort, pain, difficulty. No kind of life is worth leading if it is always an easy life. I know that your life is hard; I know that your work is hard; and hardest of all for those of you who have the highest trained consciences, and who therefore feel always how much you ought to do. I know your work is hard, and that is why I congratulate you with all my heart. I have never in my life envied a human being who led an easy life; I have envied a great many people who led difficult lives and led them well.” ~ Theodore Roosevelt, American Ideals: And Other Essays, Social and Political

Why must we be Patriotic?  Because it's hard.

Go Team Resistance!